Larry KoscielskiClick image to enlargeby Larry Koscielski

What to look out for in projection welding of fasteners

Like so many others, the resistance welding industry has seen an unprecedented rate of change in the last few years. The development of new types of steels and other materials, innovations in product designs, new coatings and new technologies are aimed at addressing ever increasing demands in occupant safety, quality and challenging component weight targets. Many of these changes have had a substantial impact on the projection welding of fasteners.

Resistance welding in general relies on the precise control of current, force and time to create a weld using resistive heating. In some regards it is a “hot forging” process. In spot welding applications, there are a number of methods employed to monitor, control and react to normal variations in the process, materials and equipment conditions. Generally these strategies leverage the fact that spot welding is a slower and much less dynamic process as compared to projection welding.

Although both processes are resistance welding, in projection welding, there is very little time to deal with variations since cycle times are dictated, in large part, by the rate of collapse of the projections. Slowing the process down has an effect on the heat that is needed for the weld. Additionally, once the projections are collapsed, further heating is detrimental to the weld. Ultimately, these two issues are the controlling factors in the times used in the set up of the weld schedule.

Projection welding is a very dynamic process. As projections collapse, this triggers effects in both the force and the weld current profiles. The total weld may be as short as 10 ms and the collapse portion may be as little as 5-6 ms. In that time the welding machine is expected to “follow up” the typical 0.5 - 1.0 mm of the projection height - while still maintaining the weld force.

As well, since most weld projections have somewhat of a inverted trapazoid profile, the area of contact becomes larger as the projections collapse. This changes the force and current density per square mm during the weld time thus adding yet another dynamic in process.

Despite these challenges, projection welding can be a very reliable process when fundamentals are applied and variables are reasonably controlled, even when welding some of the more exotic base metals like Hot Stamp and Dual Phase. Controlling these variables begins with understanding them and only then taking appropriate action. When ignored, the end results can be catastrophic.

Some of the tooling used for projection welding of fasteners.Click image to enlargeIt is becoming clear that as we see applications making use of UHSS material (Ultra High Strength Steel) that the fundamentals become even more important, the fastener design becomes critical and often the window for success is narrower, requiring users to work harder to reduce any other variables.

So what should users look out for? Well, the short answer is anything and everything that will make any difference in the way the joint (each individual projection or as a set) sees the force, and the flow of current. Time is certainly an important process variable but can be effectively controlled in modern day weld controls.

Attention needs to be given to anything in the process or machine that adds variation to how the projections are affected by force and current. In our experience, that means there is “nothing that does not matter;" it is just a matter of what degree.

The following highlights only a few of the more common conditions that can be encountered; many more exist.

Base Metal
Composition, Thickness, Condition and Coating

  • Base material - in the case of dual phase material one area of a part may react differently than another
  • Is the anti-corrosion coating thickness constant? –this is sometimes an issue when hot dipped galvanized is specified in place of electro-galvanized
  • Is the part flat in the area where the fastener will be welded?
  • Is the part coating building up on the electrodes?
  • Is the coating such that you can even weld through it?

Design, Coating and Quality

  • Is the fastener appropriate for the application? - Projection size, profile and hardness of the fastener all should be considered
  • Is there a finish coating on the fastener itself causing an issue? Sometimes these coatings build up over time on tooling or, sometimes it becomes an issue right away
  • Are the projections and electrode contact areas on the part consistent from part to part and are all projections on a given fastener dimensionally the same?

Sizing, Specification, Controls, Tooling and Maintenance

  • Are the machine, tooling and electrodes properly cooled? Is there are chance these are heating up at high production rates?
  • Does the tooling allow the part to properly sit on the electrodes?
  • Is the machine capable of following up properly?
  • Is the machine sized properly (force and current)?
  • Are the electrodes, weld pins and nut welding heads maintained properly and inspected at regular intervals?

These represent only a few highlights of the possible challenges and some ideas to consider. It is certain that change will continue, perhaps at an even accelerated pace, offering users an endless opportunity to learn and develop new solutions. These are certainly exciting times in the industryfor sure. SMT

Larry Koscielski is senior technical and strategic advisor with CenterLine (Windsor) Ltd., based in Windsor, ON.


Weld inspection with Class 2 laser

Xiris Automation Inc.’s WI-2000 weld inspection system for tube and pipe manufacturing now incorporates a Class 2 laser.

Ask the Expert: Machine Probing

Still using edge finders to pick up work coordinates and touching off cutting tools by hand? Do yourself a favour and invest in a probing system.

Weld video library grows to more than 300

Xiris Automation Inc. has expanded its weld video library to over 300 videos.

A New Look for Gear Milling?

by Andrei Petrilin & Marcel Elkouby

Edge profiling technology

Hypertherm's True Bevel is a new edge profiling technology designed to help fabricators and CNC table manufacturers achieve accurate bevel cuts more easily than before.

CWB launches national welding program

The Canadian Welding Bureau Group (CWB Group) has launched a national welding program to standardize welding education in Canada and help to fill the skilled trades gap by developing a new generation of highly skilled welders.

Manufacturing group forms Jim Flaherty bursary

Canadian Manufacturers and Exporters (CME) has unveiled the Jim Flaherty bursary for students enrolled in manufacturing programs at the University of Ontario Institute of Technology (UOIT)

Additive Test Bed

by Andrew Brooks

A low-risk, low-cost way to explore the possibilities of additive manufacturing

Flextec multi-process welder

The new high amperage Flextec 650 multi-process welder from Lincoln Electric delivers up to 815 amps of welding power. 

Direct Diode laser cutting technology

Mazak's new FG-220 DDL 3D laser cutting machine in action.

Managing the Economic Pendulum

Managing a manufacturing business in Canada has its challenges,

The Hot Spot

by Noelle Stapinsky

Addressing challenges of resistance welding on aluminum

Reaping Robotics Rewards

A Quebec manufacturer’s embrace of robotics pays off

Bumper to bumper

by Kip Hanson

No job too big or too small for Ontario welding shop

Stay In Touch

twitter facebook linkedIn