Click image to enlarge

New machine has potential to increase milling productivity 100 per cent

by Ed Robertson

Rockford Engineering Associates LLC (REALLCo)’s mission is to provide unique solutions to complex manufacturing problems.

So when the US National Institute of Standards and Technology approached the company with the challenge of developing a test machine that would demonstrate machining of titanium and other high temperature alloys on a super-stiff vibration-free (SSVF) motion platform to enhance metal removal rates and tool life, the company was ready for it.

The Rockford, IL-based company’s three main partners Kanwar Singh, John Hurd, and John Osborn, each have more than 40 years’ experience in developing custom machinery and innovative manufacturing processes.

REALLCo’s approach to research has its basis in the decades of engineering accomplishments at Ingersoll, where REALLCo’s principals worked. "We didn’t work on standard products,” says Kanwar Singh, "we offered manufacturing engineering solutions to our customers. Our M.O. is the same today.”

Singh relates the circa-1978 story of an aerospace company wanting to triple the production rate of a very large titanium component. Many machine tool companies were invited to bid on the equipment and processes. Singh and Ingersoll took a different approach. "Our solution was to start with a clean slate to envision the process of cutting titanium from scratch,” he says. "Otherwise, to continue with the tools and processes they were currently using, they were perpetuating their obsolescence.”

Singh’s clean-sheet approach takes the exact opposite path. "Define your optimum cutting tool first, develop spindle specs to support the tool, then machine-tool specs to support the spindle,” he says. "We were determined to find out how titanium cuts optimally based on its mechanical and physical properties, cutting edge material, tool edge prep, optimum angles, and ideal speed and chip thickness.”

The aerospace company agreed with Singh’s approach and funded a six-month study. "We basically wrote a textbook for them on titanium cutting,” Singh relates. For example, the specific amount of energy consumption required to cut a unit of 4340 steel and titanium is about the same, say 1 for steel and 1.1 for titanium. "But the speed at which you can cut steel is about three times that of cutting titanium,” Singh explains. Steel has a low melting point, conducts heat well, and transfers about 80 per cent of the heat energy at the point of plastic deformation into the chip.

By comparison, titanium has a high melting point, low thermal conductivity, and transfers less than 20 per cent of the heat to the chip and the part, with the rest going to the cutting edge. With three times the cutting forces needed for cutting titanium as opposed to steel for the same metal removal rate, only massive machine structures could provide the necessary rigidity and torque. "There was no real innovation,” Singh says. "A machine with a cubic-meter work zone for milling titanium parts would look like a battleship.”

Support the Spindles

One of the findings of the 1978 study on cutting titanium became the basis for the SSVF machine - that cutting tools do not fail from wear as they typically do in iron and steel. Intense heat and pressure encountered in cutting titanium causes thermal micro-fissures along the rake face. "Any vibration at the tool/workpiece interface helps propagate these fissures and eventually cause the failure,” Singh says. "It was clear that a very low-compliance structure with high damping characteristics was required for machining titanium.”

REALLCo engineers hypothesized that machine tools are made up of passive and active elements. Passive elements are the structural metal segments; active elements are the bearings that facilitate motion between them. Mechanical bearings, regardless of the preload, always have some compliance and typically low damping ratio.

For the NIST study, REALLCo offered a refined and enhanced version of membrane dual-restrictor (MDR) hydrostatic bearings in which positive, infinite and/or negative stiffness could be achieved. "Besides the infinite stiffness, a squeezed film of oil is inherently damped,” Singh says. "We theorized negative stiffness at the bearings allows us the provision to compensate for any compliance in the structure.”

Click image to enlarge

Proof

REALLCo then built a milling machine to validate the MDR hydrostatic bearings contribution to the stiffness and damping of the structure. Ultimate proof of the SSVF concept would not only be in ultra-high stiffness, but also in improved metal-removal rate or increased tool life or both.

The test machine’s spindle is designed with constant-flow hydrostatic conical bearings for high stiffness and damping, powered by a high-torque/low-speed torque motor. Calculated and measured stiffness of NIST machine’s spindle was approximately 12,000,000 lb/in., where conventional bearing spindles are between 5,000,000 and 6,000,000/in. Calculated and measured aggregate machine stiffness at the spindle face is approximately 2,000,000 lb/in, four times greater than the current state-of-the-art at 500,000 lb/in.

Major tooling suppliers were invited to submit their latest products for test cuts on the new machine. "All submitted tools were a success not only in validating the SSVF concept, but in also improving tool life an average of 75 per cent,” Singh says. "We believe that performance goals were met or exceeded largely through the machine’s extremely high static stiffness and damping characteristics. Indeed, the test tools selected more than stood up to the challenge as well.”

The test machine belongs to REALLCo and is available to demo the SSVF concept as well as new and emerging cutting tool technologies. For more information visit REALLCo oline.

Ontario gives Sheridan College $550k for skills training

Sheridan’s Davis Campus has been handed $559,837 in funding from the province for its Pre-Apprenticeship Programs.

Iscar announces management reorganization

Iscar Canada has reorganized its management team.

Machine combines Swiss style CNC machining with laser cutting, welding

Tsugami Automation has introduced a combination machine that combines Swiss style CNC machining, laser cutting and laser welding into one machine with a single shared platform.

Shop Thought

Have you had trouble finding skilled trade workers for your manufacturing operation? If so, how have you addressed the issue?

Leviathan lathes

by Kip Hanson

The benefits of vertical multi-tasking machines for large part machining

Expansion strategies

Market diversification as a competitive tool for manufacturing growth

by Tim Wilson 

Canada is an energy giant.

Cutting Tools in Israel: Pushing the Innovation Envelope

Iscar customers go behind the scenes to gain insights into cutting tool R&D, manufacturing

If you want to reduce your total production costs, increase your productivity. And the best way to do that is to increase speeds and feeds. Focus on that, and you will cut the cost of production in the first year by 15 to 20 per cent.

Back to the future

by Mary Scianna

Shop Metalworking Technology revisits manufacturers we've profiled in previous issues to see how they're preparing for the future

Sandvik Coromant Canada holds 1st Manufacturing Day event

Sandvik Coromant celebrated Manufacturing Day in Canada on October 3 with 160 high school students enrolled in manufacturing technology programs in local Ontario schools.

Smart Machining

The problem
Improving productivity in a highly competitive aerospace market

The solution
A Makino machining cell adds new level of five axis automation and productivity in titanium machining

Machining cell helps aerospace parts maker improve productivity

Breaking Additive Manufacturing Barriers: A Bigger Build

New robotics-enabled technology promises to break some major additive barriers

A critical link

by Ethan Weikleenget

Grinding wheel flanges and personal safety

GF Machining brings OPC UA to North America

GF Machining Solutions now offers North American manufacturers its Open Platform Communications (OPC) Unified Architecture (UA) interface Version 1.0 as a single connectivity solution.

Industry association supports skills training for youth

The Canadian Tooling and Machining Association (CTMA) is launching two skills training programs for youth to help fill the skilled trades gap in Canada: the Introductory Trades Training program and the Ontario Manufacturing Learning Consortium, a partnership initiative between CTMA, Canadian Manufacturers and Exporters (CME), Ontario Aerospace Council (OAC) and the Organization of Canadian Nuclear Industries (OCI).

Chatter-free machining of aluminum

A demonstration of Iscar's new four-flute ChatterFree solid mill line of cutting tools cutting aluminum.

Stay In Touch

twitter facebook linkedIn