Doosan's DBC 160 is a multi-purpose, high speed and high precision horizontal boring mill.Click image to enlargeby Kip Hanson 

When machined parts are the size of locomotives and pickup trucks, finding safe, efficient ways of handling them is critical to the success of any manufacturing company

It may seem obvious to anyone in the machining industry, but large boring mills and gantry style machining centres are quite expensive, as are the parts made on them. Cranes are needed to load and unload such machine tools, huge slabs of concrete required to support their extreme mass, and highly-skilled machinists available to operate them. The stakes are high, with billing rates in the hundreds of dollars per hour range and cycle times that may span days. For the owners and operators of these machines, it’s crucial to aim for the highest spindle utilization possible. 

Zeroing in on downtime
One way to achieve at least some of this goal is with zero point fixturing systems. That’s according to Peter Zagorskis, inside sales coordinator at Mississauga-based machine tool distributor Megatel Inc., who says a number of his customers have either purchased an off-the-shelf quick change system or built their own. 

“We offer a number of machine tools with rotary-style pallet changers, but these aren’t always feasible when you’re talking about ten ton workpieces,” he says. “By mounting the part to a quick change fixture of some kind, it can not only move from machine to machine with ease, but setup time becomes practically zero—you just position the part on the machine and go. Just as importantly, you don’t have to invest a quarter-million dollars in a massive pallet changer.”

This Fermat machine, the WFT 13, is a universal boring and milling machine for efficient processing of large and heavy workpieces. IMAGE: MegatelClick image to enlargeAnother way to increase large part machining efficiency is by supersizing the table. For instance, double-column machining centres and boring mills are often equipped with right angle heads, speeders, and tools too large to fit through the toolchanger. Carl Barthelson, regional sales manager at Doosan Machine Tools America, says if the table is large enough, these can be “parked” to one side in a wine rack-style fixture, then picked up automatically by the machine as needed. In addition, workers might actually be able to load and unload parts on one end while parts are being produced parts on the other. 

“On machines with generous X axis travels, it’s pretty easy to establish A and B work zones to keep the operator safe while the machine is running,” he says. “I worked at a job shop in Schenectady, New York, making automotive stamping dies and turbine components for the power generation industry, and this practice saved us a lot of time—we could be roughing out a mould cavity on one end while setting up a finishing operation on the opposite side.”

Another way to increase machine uptime is with spindle probing. Assuming the machine tool is accurate enough (which virtually all newer ones are), it’s often more efficient to simply measure sofa sized parts in place rather than carting them off to a CMM for inspection. 

Take it offline
Using a highly accurate machining centre can be a perfectly acceptable way to validate features and inspect parts, thus eliminating the need to re-fixture them offline. And quick change fixtures are a great way to reduce setup related downtime, regardless of machine size. But perhaps the best way to keep expensive spindles producing nearly non-stop is with an automatic pallet changer, noted Robb Hudson, CEO of Mitsui Seiki (U.S.A.) Inc.

“I think zero point systems are fine when on smaller components, but when you’re talking about the massive castings and forgings you see in the aerospace and energy sectors, I would prefer palletization,” he says. “In this scenario, you’ll have a dedicated load and unload station away from the machine, with ready access to a crane or hoist. The operator can work at ground level to get large, bulky components mounted in place, after which the automation system will shuttle the pallet directly to an available machine, or back to a storage position for future scheduling.”

Sikorsky’s Precision Components Development Center consists of a Phoenix VTL, a 1,900 mm and two 1,200 mm Mitsui Seiki five axis machining centres, load/unload stations, and a Fastems automatic pallet handling system.	IMAGE: Lynn Gorman CommunicationsClick image to enlarge“Palletization is as much about safety as it is machine efficiency,” adds David Suica, president of automation system provider Fastems LLC. “Without a pallet system, the operator’s going to be standing up there on the table trying to maneuver some huge workpiece into position. He’s several feet in the air, crane control in hand. There are chips and cutting fluid underfoot. Considering the size of the parts, it can be dangerous. And while all this is going in, the machine’s sitting idle.”

Suica says that shops thinking about a pallet system should also consider ways to more effectively manage their cutting tools and toolholders—when large machine tools are automated (or any machine tool, for that matter), throughput goes up substantially, making it increasingly likely there won’t be enough cutting tools available to complete whatever work is in the queue. 

“Suddenly you’re able to produce multiple parts and operations unattended, but many standalone boring mills and machining centres have relatively small tool capacities,” says Suica. “That’s why we often suggest a centralized tool system. This not only provides hundreds or perhaps thousands of tool storage positions, but because they can be shared across multiple machine tools, it actually decreases overall tooling costs. Between this and an automated pallet changer, it’s pretty easy to double machine capacity.”

Doubling down
Mitsui Seiki works closely with Fastems and other automation providers. Like Suica, Hudson believes that the larger the machine investment, the more important it is to automate. “We have several installations where we’re taking large, heavy, and very expensive raw material components—typically titanium or similar superalloys—and loading them onto pallets for offline storage,” he says. “A cell controller equipped with scheduling software then plans production based on what tools and machines are available, maximizing the efficiency of each.”

According to Hudson, the OEE in these installations can hit 90-percent or greater, and the chance of scrapping out a workpiece costing several hundred thousand dollars drops significantly. Fewer machines are needed, investment is maximized, as is the flexibility to meet customer demands quickly. 

Loading/unloading area of the MDR-750 FMS ONE manufacturing system from FMS provider Fastems LLC.   IMAGE: Lynn Gorman CommunicationsClick image to enlargeGranted, there are some drawbacks. Pallet systems and centralized tool storage hubs consume considerable floor space. Implementation of such systems requires months or sometimes years of planning, Employees will need training, and old school machinists must be brought into the automation fold. But for those shops that have made the leap to a large-scale FMS, the ROI is quite fast. 

“We’re seeing a number of large manufacturers moving in this direction,” Hudson says. “They’re looking to reduce the amount of direct labour, in part because it’s very challenging to find skilled operators. To that point, I think automated environments are much more enticing to the next generation of people entering the trades, who will take on roles like cell technician and automation engineer rather than machine operator. Automation is simply a good move for everyone involved.”

One final piece of advice comes from Doosan’s Barthelson, who suggests that prospective automation customers shouldn’t sell themselves short on machine capacity. “I worked with a shop recently that was making fracking blocks roughly one-metre square,” he says. “They were looking at a machine just large enough to fit the parts, and my question to the owner was, ‘What’s the likelihood of producing even larger fracking blocks next year, or the year after that?’”

The message is clear: machining needs change. And where a large boring mill can easily machine smaller parts, a smaller boring mill is limited to small ones. Says Barthelson, “If you’re looking at the big picture, you want to buy the most capable machine possible as an investment in the future, and automation is part of that.” SMT

Watch for the Piranha

by Kip Hanson | photos by David Afriat

Quebec cutting tool manufacturer achieves new levels of precision and productivity

Manufacturing continues slow, but steady growth

The latest manufacturing statistics in Canada and the US for December 2014 point to continued, albeit slow growth.

Great Expectations

by Noelle Stapinsky

Using R&D to go beyond demand to supply future needs 

camInstructor online and hybrid Mastercam training courses offer Mastercam certification

The technology training experts at camInstructor are offering their Mastercam training courses in both online and hybrid formats.

Hurco acquires Milltronics and Takumi

Hurco Companies Inc. has acquired two machine tool builders, Milltronics Manufacturing Co. and Takumi Machinery Co. Ltd.

Public likes register for skilled trades people

People in Ontario like the idea of a public register to verify skilled tradepeople's qualifications, according to a poll conducted for the Ontario College of Trades.

Advanced Manufacturing Expo


Advanced Manufacturing Expo September 23-24, The International Centre, Hall 5, Mississuaga, ON.

Visit AME online for details and registration.

Mazak gets connected

First machine tool OEM to adopt MT Connect at its US manufacturing facility

Mazak Corp., Florence, KY, has become the first machine tool OEM to adopt a open communications protocol MT Connect at its manufacturing facility.

Plug and Play Profitability

by Kip Hanson

Quebec job shop meets with success on its first foray into robotics

Jamie Schell joins Autodesk Canada

Jamie Schell has joined Autodesk as a member of the DMG CAM AMER product specialist sales team.

West Coast Wonder

Story by Kip Hanson  •  Images by Derek Ford

BC design and manufacturing company adopts a five axis machining strategy

Machining case study: Ahead of the Curve

by Kip Hanson

Calgary job shop realizes big benefits from its investment in advanced machine tools

Double column VMC

The V2000 vertical machining centre from First uses MEEHANITE cast iron for all major machine parts and its double column design provides stable conditions for heavy-duty cutting.

Going places: Aerospace Manufacturing

by Andrew Brooks

Opportunities in Canada’s aerospace market

Crushing it with Compacts

by Kip Hanson

Three-axis machining centres have long dominated the job shop world. But given that high-mix, low-volume work is the new normal for most machine shops,
are they still the best choice?

Stay In Touch

twitter facebook linkedIn