Click image to enlarge

What is the true cost of financing machinery and equipment?

by Daniel Wittlin and Adrian Isaacs

When looking to get a bank loan to finance machinery many companies only consider the rate of interest quoted by their bank.

There are a number of other factors to consider. In this article, we are going to elaborate on three of these: The hidden costs of financing; Consider the small print – the General Security Agreement; Perception of Debt. 

Before reviewing these items, a brief recap of some of the key differences between financing and leasing is important. Financing is a loan and the manufacturer (or borrower) holds title to the asset. The bank quotes a rate of interest along with various terms to be considered. With leasing, the lessor takes title to the asset and charges a monthly “rental” type payment. At the end of the lease, the company can purchase the equipment; usually it’s a predetermined percentage of the original equipment cost or for a nominal value, depending on who you lease with. 

Hidden costs of financing
In addition to the actual rate of interest to be paid when obtaining a bank loan to finance the purchase of machinery, there are many other hidden or indirect costs that need to be considered:

Legal fees: Banks often have comprehensive loan agreements which may require preparation or review by a lawyer. Based on a lawyer’s hourly rates, this could be sizeable costs to the loan. Plus, the manufacturer may also be responsible for the banks legal fees, if any. 

Requirement to prepare ongoing financial statements during the term of the loan: Banks often require an annual audit or review engagement level financial statements done by an external firm of Chartered Accountants. These types of engagements typically cost from $5,000 per year and up, depending on the size and complexity of the business.

Costs of generating and reporting ongoing financial information: Banks require ongoing financial reporting during the term of the loan, which can include: providing monthly or quarterly financial statements and Accounts Receivable information. The manufacturer should consider the costs for the time required for internal staff to generate this information.

Costs to do the accounting for setting up the asset and loan on the books: There are costs for the company’s controller or bookkeeper to do all of the accounting for the financing, including the time to:  track the asset on a fixed asset register, compute the annual depreciation and amortization, record the liability to the bank, account for the monthly loan payments between principal and interest, and reconcile the amount owing to the bank. 

Costs for income tax preparation: Our external accountant needs to track the asset by tax class and then compute the annual Capital Cost Allowances allowed by CRA. 

The Small Print – General Security Agreements
It’s important to be aware there is often terminology or language in the Loan Agreement which will give the bank a charge over all of the assets of the manufacturer; even if you are just financing one machine. This type of agreement is called a General Security Agreement (“GSA”) and almost every company that has an operating line of credit with a bank has signed one.

In the event of default, it gives the bank the ability to seize and sell off the majority of the assets of the manufacturer to repay the loan
including accountant’s receivable, equipment and inventory. Whereas typically, the leasing company’s only security is the machine they leased. 

Perception of Debt
Another factor for manufacturers to consider is that when they finance equipment, the amount they borrow appears on their financials as debt.

If the business is seeking to raise funds generally, the existence of these types of loans can be negatively perceived. Often the amount on your operating line of credit is negatively impacted by your equipment loan, reducing the financing available to the company. Every lender has a limit in how much they can finance a client.

Manufacturers should evaluate leasing their capital equipment as a viable alternative to financing with their bank. If we have learned anything from the past few years it’s that anything can change at any time. Leasing is also an easy way to spread your financing needs to multiple sources, while allowing you to keep a strong relationship with your bank by having your operating line with them. The total cost for leasing vs. bank loans in today’s market are similar and usually the leasing company will finance a higher amount against the machines with less security. This is not to say that solid banking relationship is not a cornerstone to a successful company, it is. But just like you wouldn’t want your entire business reliant on one customer, so too should be your philosophy with your business’s finances.

Once you have evaluated all of the pros and cons of loan vs. lease, leasing is a viable solution for manufacturers. SMT

Daniel Wittlin is president & CEO and Adrian Isaacs, CA is a vice president of Enable Capital Corp., Toronto. 


Machine tool suppliers hold 14th Joint Open House 2019

Hundreds of manufacturers attended the 14th annual machine tool distributors' Joint Open House in southwestern Ontario in April.

Learning to program for high speed and five axis machining


Users of Delcam PowerMill CAM system had the opportunity to learn about the latest developments for high speed and five axis machining at the company's annual update meeting in Windsor, ON.

Bentley expands 3D printing to produce thousands of new components

Bentley Motors, perhaps the most famous luxury car brand in the world, is embracing a future that includes leaning on the advantages of additive manufacturing.

Down to the wire

Controlling consumable costs in wire EDM

by Jim Barnes

Wire is one of the most visible costs in EDM. As a primary consumable in the process, most owners are interested in reducing their usage of wire. As with any exercise in cost reduction, though, it is important not to confuse price with cost.

Paying a Premium

by Kip Hanson photos by David Afriat

Quebec manufacturer Usinage DDR rejects the job shop status quo in favour of automation

Canada's economic plan offers some manufacturing support

Canadian Manufacturers & Exporters (CME) welcomes the $100 billion federal stimulus package aimed at creating one million jobs over the next three years.

Ford, Magna investing big in advanced R&D

Two of Canada's major manufacturers, Ford and Magna, are investing millions of dollars in advanced research and development for connected vheicles and services and artificial intellingence.

Heavyweight machining capabilities

The Annihilator from Quickmill. The rigid gantry design, the high speed axis drive system, the heavy duty spindle options, all allow for very fast processing times. The Annihilator is for those who need a lot more than regular performance, it's for those who need heavyweight machining capabilities.

Bystonic adds training manager

Bystronic Canada has appointed Wilson Villamizar as Application and Training Manager.

Huge investment in clean steelmaking tech in Hamilton

ArcelorMittal Dofasco and the Ontario government are joining forces on a multi-billion dollar project aimed at transforming the province into a world-leading producer of green steel.

Pressing issues clouding manufacturing’s future

A host of pressing issues are hampering Canadian manufacturing’s economic recovery and clouding its outlook despite strong demand for goods, according to the results of a national business outlook survey of manufacturing companies released by Canadian Manufacturers & Exporters (CME) today.


Iscar announces management reorganization

Iscar Canada has reorganized its management team.

DiPaolo expands with new hire Terry Kunath

Terry Kunath has joined DiPaolo Machine Tools as an applications engineer.

9% global growth for laser cutting machine market: Report

The outlook for the global laser cutting market is good according to a forecast by Technavio, a technology research and advisory company. The company forecasts the market will experience close to a 9 per cent Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR) between 2016 and 2020.

Stay In Touch

twitter facebook linkedIn