Chander Bhardwaj is the general manager of Zoller Canada Inc.Click image to enlargeby Staff Writer

Shop Metalworking Technology has some questions for Zoller’s Chander Bhardwaj about offline tool presetting

Chander Bhardwaj is the general manager of Zoller Canada Inc.’s Mississauga facility. He’s been with the company for more than 17 years, and during that time, has traveled throughout Canada and spoken with thousands of machine shops. Here’s what he has to say about offline tool presetting
and other productivity-boosting technology.

Shop: I’m sure you’ve heard from the owners and managers of Canadian machine shops that offline tool presetters
are expensive. What do you tell them?
Bhardwaj: I tell them that presetters are not expensive. Far from it. Assuming a shop has five CNC machine tools, a billing rate of $75 per hour, and a conservative time savings of four hours a week on each machine, that comes out to $75,000 annually. For an investment of around $20,000, that’s a very quick ROI. Add to this the reduced risk of fat-fingering an offset and crashing a machine that might cost twenty or thirty thousand dollars to repair and you’ll quickly conclude that an offline presetter is one of the best investments you can make.

Shop: Setting aside any investment costs, presetters are just one more thing for an increasingly unskilled workforce to master. Thoughts?
Bhardwaj: It’s the companies with less skilled workers who need tool presetters the most. In these situations, an engineer or programmer determines the assembly parameters for each toolholder and cutting tool. The tool crib then sets those tools exactly as outlined on the job’s setup sheet and sends the offsets to the machine control. The only thing the operator has to do is stick each toolholder in the right pocket, and if the shop has RFID capability (which I highly recommend), even that step becomes foolproof. The costs of scrapping a workpiece or damaging the machine are simply too high to do anything else. 

For shops looking for Lights Out Operation, Zoller Automation is a solution where tools can be withdrawn from Storage & Assemble, delivered to the machine by AGV/Carts,  and loaded into the machine magazine automatically by robots. The complete automation is controlled through the Zoller TMS as such. Which means there are no mistakes and production continues.Click image to enlargeShop: But I already have a Renishaw tool probe on my CNC machine. Why should I bother with offline presetting?
Bhardwaj: In-machine probing systems are great for inspecting parts, establishing work coordinates, and checking for tool wear and broken tools during the machining process. They’re also invaluable for anyone engaged in lights-out manufacturing. However, using these systems to establsih tool lengths and diameters during setup or when replacing worn tools mid-process only adds to machine downtime. I’ll also argue that offline tool presetting—Zoller’s, at least—is much more accurate than an in-machine probing system.

Shop: What about tool management software, or TMS—why is that needed? Isn’t CAM software good enough for keeping track of tools?
Bhardwaj: I think every shop should use a tool management solution. There are several reasons for this, but the main one is that many shops do not use a single CAD/CAM system, nor do they have a single programmer. This not only creates inconsistencies in tool data but leads to duplication of efforts in defining the different parameters and databases needed for various jobs. With a tool management system, there’s a single source of the truth. Fully defined cutting tools and toolholders with relevant application information can be downloaded one time from the manufacturer or other source, saving time and eliminating mistakes. This database can be accessed by all departments simultaneously, eliminating confusion and duplicate efforts.

Shop: I’ve heard that some shops use a tool presetter to inspect cutting tools. Is that really necessary, and if so, why?
Bhardwaj: It is necessary, and here’s why: From our own research and what we hear from our customers, there’s a fair amount of dimensional and geometric variance in even high-quality cutting tools. Unless you’re aware of this variance, it’s easy to scrap out a close tolerance part that might be quite expensive. And even with more forgiving workpieces, unexpected variance in the cutting tool leads to variance in the machining process, downtime for part measurement and adjustment, and so on. Cutting tool inspection is really no different than checking the raw material or any other purchased product that comes in the receiving door. It just makes good sense and saves lot of money and effort.

Shop: We’ve had problems with hoarding and missing cutting tools. Does Zoller have anything to solve this problem? 
Bhardwaj: You’re not alone. Many machine shops go to start a job only to discover they’re out of a certain insert or end mill. It happens all the time. They must then expedite the tools and let the machine sit idle while waiting or set up something else until the tool arrives. It’s expensive, and worse, it could jeopardize their relationship with a customer. This is why smart storage cabinets are a must, especially when used in conjunction with a tool management system. Such a strategy completely eliminates the scenario just described, while also giving management complete visibility into tool location and availability. It also lets them know which tools are used most often and where, usage and performance trends, and a wealth of other information that would otherwise remain hidden. Simply put, a robust tool management strategy can save shops a huge amount of money.

 

Shop: Our shop has older CNC equipment. Is it still possible to do tool life management and integrate with a tool presetter?
Bhardwaj: Simple tasks like sending tool offsets from the presetter to a CNC machine tool is never a problem, no matter how old the equipment. On the other hand, tool life monitoring and management is possible in two ways. For machine tools with RFID capability, tracking usage is quite straightforward. You simply tell the presetter to write the tool life status to the chip or an external database, and then read it into the machine as the tool is loaded into the magazine or turret. When the job is done, this value is written back and updated automatically, or if the tool has reached its end of life, the machine either stops and waits or calls up a replacement tool. If the control is incapable of these functions (which is increasingly rare), Zoller has begun offering a cloud-based system called zidCode 4.0. This relies on a presetter-generated label with a QR code rather than an RFID tag and exchanges offset and tool life information via a web service. It’s a great solution for any shop that wants to prevent offset-related crashes, save time during setups, and take the first steps towards digital manufacturing. 

Shop: Did we miss any important points?
Bhardwaj: I’ve been doing this a long time, and I’ve seen recently that the industry is moving towards a totally new way of working. People are increasingly aware of the benefits that come with offline tool presetting and some of the other technologies discussed here. Even for shops that only have one or two machines, the goal should be to maximize the amount of time spent cutting parts, not wasting time by setting tools on the machine. Also, the combination of tool management, storage solutions, and offline presetter helps to reduce inventory and time lost searching for tools, further increasing productivity. Perhaps best of all is that everything is connected digitally. Everyone’s working from the same playbook and has visibility to all the shop’s tooling assets. It’s just a huge, huge advantage. SMT

New growth and innovation platform to support Ontario technology cluster

The federal government is investing $52.4 million in a growth and innovation platform in the Waterloo–Toronto–Ottawa corridor.

Automotive sector leads manufacturing activity gains in the U.S.

Manufacturing activity in the U.S climbed sharply in March, led by increases in automotive output. This marked the third straight monthly gain in U.S. factory activity.

Canada’s largest trade route to US now completely blocked

The blockade at Windsor’s Ambassador Bridge, the largest trade route between Canada and the U.S., is getting worse as it enters its fourth day.

CTMA's Apprentice Awards open for nominations

The Canadian Tooling and Machining Association's (CTMA) Annual Apprentice Awards will continue in 2020, despite the COVID-19 lockdown.

Rethinking tooling costs

by Ronnie O’Byrne

Cutting tools represent only a fraction of total machining costs, so how can you gain real cost savings?

Tooling costs in 95 per cent of machine shops represent approximately 3 per cent, on average, of the total manufacturing costs.

Metalformers optimistic about 1st quarter conditions

Metalforming companies are viewing the first quarter of 2022 with increased optimism for improved business conditions, according to the January 2022 Precision Metalforming Association (PMA) Business Conditions Report.

Absolute Machine Tools sold to employee ownership trust

Absolute Machine Tools has been sold to, and is now owned by, an Employee Stock Ownership Trust (ESOP).

Manufacturing capacity utilization rate on the rise

Canadian manufacturers continue to increase their factory capacity utilization.

FABTECH 2013

North America's premier event for metal fabricating, forming and welding takes place in Chicago, IL November 18-21

North America's largest event for the metal fabricating and forming industry takes place November 18 to 21 at McCormick Place, Chicago, IL.

The annual event attracts fabricators from across North America. This year, event organizers are expecting more than 35,000 attendees to visit the 1,500 exhibitors already registered for the event.

This year's events includes an expanded education program with more than 100 sessions, including 64 new courses that have not been offered at previous FABTECH events. New sessions include presentations on trends and advances in laser technology and new workshops about lean manufacturing, workforce development and press brake operation skills.

Special events include a welding competition, new product presentations, a reception for women in manufacturing and a "cocktails and comedy" event on Wednesday, November 20.

For event details and for registration, visit FABTECH online at www.fabtechexpo.com.

SHOW HOURS

Monday, November 18, 10:00 am - 6:00 pm 
Tuesday, November 19, 9:00 am - 5:00 pm 
Wednesday, November 20, 9:00 am - 5:00 pm 
Thursday, November 21, 9:00 am - 3:00 pm

EVENT HIGHLIGHTS

  •  State of the Industry: Executive Outlook

Open to all attendees, the event takes place Tuesday, November 19, 12:30 pm - 1:30 pm at the FABTECH Theatre, Grand Concourse.

  • ·      Solutions for a Qualified Workforce Pipline

Open to all attendees, panel discussion takes place Wednesday, November 20 12:30 pm - 1:30 pm at the FABTECH Theatre, Grand Concourse.

  • ·      Robotic Arc Welding Contents

Robotic welding technicians compete on Tuesday, November 19 and Wednesday, November 20 in the North Hall, Booth N2099.

  • ·      Cocktails and Comedy

Doors open at 5:00 pm at the FABTECH Theatre, Grand Concourse, on Wednesday, November 20.

EDUCATIONAL EVENTS: EDITOR'S PICKS

·      Precision Punch & Cutting Technology 8:00 am - 10:00 am Monday, November 18

·      Automation Solutions for Press Brakes with Tech Tour 1:30 pm - 3:30 pm, Monday, November 18

·      Welding Disimilar Metals conference 8:15 am - 2:30 pm, Monday, November 18

·      Introduction to Laser Cutting Best Practices 8:00 am - 10:00 am, Tuesday, November 19

·      New Developments in Waterjet Cutting 10:30 am - 12:30 pm, Tuesday, November 19

·      Inspecting and Troubleshooting Welded Tube 1:30 pm - 3:30 pm, Tuesday, November 19

·      Innovations in Plasma Cutting 8:00 am - 10:00 am Wednesday, November 20

·      Game Changing Technology to Increase Productivity 1:30 pm - 3:30 pm Wednesday, November 20

·      High Energy Density Welding Processes 8:00 am - 11:00 am Wednesday, November 20

Check event details online at www.fabtechexpo.com/learn#.

 

Tech Tips: Smarter drilling

by Sam Matsumoto

Selecting the right drill for stainless steel and titanium

Haas donates $50,000 to Skills Ontario organization

Haas is a long-time supporter of skills training in North America and this year was no exception with the company donating $50,000 to Skills Ontario during the Skills Ontario competition in May, held at the Toronto Congress Centre.

Wilson Tool changes Exacta name in Canada

Wilson Tool International, White Bear Lake, MN, has changed the name of Exacta Precision and Exacta FabTool to Wilson Tool Canada.

Hexagon opens certification centre in Montreal

Hexagon’s Manufacturing Intelligence division today announced the opening of a dedicated Hexagon certification centre in Montreal.

Workflow tools provider Authentise makes acquisition

Authentise, a Philadelphia, Pa., based provider of workflow tools for additive manufacturing, has acquired Elements Technology Platform, a provider of self-serve workflow tools for manufacturing.

Morphing metal: future of robotics?

Engineers at Cornell Univeristy in Ithaca, NY, have developed a hybrid material comprised of stiff metal and soft, prorous rubber foam that combines the best properties of both-stiffness when it's required and elasticity when a change of shape is needed. And, perhaps of greatest importance, the material has the ability to self-heal if damaged.

Stay In Touch

twitter facebook linkedIn