Here's a Hot TipClick image to enlargeProjection welding of fasteners to hot stamped boron components

Automotive component assemblies often incorporate projection welding of fasteners. And more and more manufacturers are using hot stamped boron steel, like Usibor, resulting in lighter weight components with increased tensile strength (up to 1500 megapascals (MPa). This helps them meet regulatory requirements while maintaining 5-star safety ratings.

There are a number of manufacturing issues that come up when projection welding fasteners onto hot stamped boron steel components. In most cases, the weld nuts and studs used are considerably softer than the 1500 MPa stamping. This large change in hardness can cause the weld projections on the fastener to collapse prior to a successful fusion of the parts. This results in vaporized projections, leading to extended weld times in an effort to forge the materials. The result is weak inconsistent torque and push out values as well as deformed fastener threads.

Also of concern is the consistency of the base material due to in-house processing. Oven temperatures, heat cycle times, water flow rates, water temperatures, and quench times all lead to material variations. This leads to inconsistent interface resistance and in turn leads to inconsistent heat generation.

Figure 1: CD fast rise to current 57 ka in 3 ms.Click image to enlargeComparing processes to achieve success
Researchers have compared mid-frequency direct current (MFDC) processes with capacitor discharge (CD) weld controls to arrive at the best process for the application – and the one that can meet the manufacturing challenges identified.

Typical weld times with MFDC processes are in the range of 6-10 cycles (100 milliseconds (ms)/160ms). These longer weld times make it almost impossible to utilize the high contact resistance present in the hot stamped boron steels. Without being able to capture the heat on the rising edge of the current profile, the weld becomes more of a forging process than a projection welding process. The longer weld times also cause deformation of the nut and damage to any included threads.

Figure 2 (left):  M8 Nut welded to 2mm boron. Figure 3 (right):  M6 Nut welded to 2mm boron.Click image to enlargeCD weld controls can deliver a high peak current in 3ms and total pulse widths on the order of 10-ms. (See Figure 1). These shorter weld times allow concentrated heating at the projection tip with subsequent increases in local deformation. This enhanced localized deformation improves both performance and reliability of the welds.

The process can produce higher than normal pushout and torque values, which meet automotive requirements. It can also extend electrode life. (See Figure 2 and Figure 3 for examples.)


FIgure 4: The most common parameters used in CD welding.Click image to enlargeMaking the most out of the  CD welding process
To get the full benefit of the shorter cycle times associated with CD welding, welder manufacturers must properly size the weld cylinders, weld ram, and fast follow-up mechanism to maintain force through the projection collapse. Without this optimization, expulsion is unavoidable.

For each welding application, a laboratory study is recommended to evaluate the welding parameters using hot stamped parts to determine the optimal fast follow-up system. It is always best to use processed parts when evaluating system mechanical response for this part of the process. In addition, the projection welder frame must be able to accommodate the added stresses caused by higher forces and increased rates of acceleration with little or no deflection.

The CD weld process produces a rapid pulse of current that creates instantaneous heating at the weld interface. This is similar to a constant voltage feedback – small changes in current based upon resistance changes, while maintaining appropriate heat generation.

A comprehensive weld monitor is a must-have when using a CD welding process. Once baseline process parameters have been established, high and low windows (or envelope), should be set to ensure the process stays within the limits. Figure 4 shows the most common parameters used in CD welding.


To sum it up
Customer installations and laboratory testing have shown CD welding to produce superior results when projection welding fasteners to hot stamped boron steel. The test results exceed manufacturers’ required push out and torque requirements with no damage to the fastener threads. Consistent results have virtually eliminated costly post-weld inspections.

In addition, CD welding equipment costs less than the larger MFDC power supplies, with the added additional benefit of lower facilities cost.

But remember, the CD power supply is only the beginning of the process; the complete answer requires high current, high weld force, short weld times, fast follow-up mechanisms, and rigid frame welders. CD systems often use higher forces (compared to MFDC variants) to ensure proper follow-up. SMT 

This technical article is provided courtesy of Amada Weld Tech.

Prima Industrie launches additive business

Prima Industrie, parent company of Prima Power, is getting into the additive business with the launch of its new division Prima Additive and the introduction of a new additive machine, the Print Sharp 250.

Business groups call on Ottawa to prevent labour disruption at CP Rail

Canadian businesses are calling on the federal government to prevent a Canadian Pacific Railway work stoppage.

Border vaccine mandate not only ailment to supply chain issues

The federal government's planned  enforcement of its vaccine mandate for all truck drivers crossing the international border will likely further aggravate chaotic transit times for job shops waiting on equipment and parts deliveries from the U.S..

COVID-19 lockdown of Shanghai snarling global supply chains

The two-stage lockdown of Shanghai, China’s largest city, could make supply chain issues worse than the initial COVID lockdowns, logistics companies are warning manufacturers whose supply chains depend on China.

Alex Livingston retires from Tungaloy Canada

After 20 years of service at Tungaloy Canada, Alex Livingston has announced his retirement.

Canada to aid business with revenue loss of 30% or more

The Federal government says it will help pay wages of small and medium businesses and charities during the coronavirus outbreak that have revenue losses of 30 per cent or more.

Invest in Canada: Government message at Paris Air Show

The Canadian government thinks global companies should invest in Canada's world-class aerospace sector and that's the message it delivered at the 2017 International Paris Air Show, which runs June 19 to 25.

Viking, PAL Aerospace partner to fight fires

Canadian owned and operated aerospace companies Viking Air Ltd. and PAL Aerospace Canada have partnered to support wildland firefighters around the globe.

Wilson Tool celebrates new Canadian manufacturing plant

Wilson Tool's newest manufacturing plant in Canada, a 4,366 sq m (47,000 sq ft) facility in Toronto, is one of seven production facilities the company operates around the around the globe, and it's one of two operations in Canada.

Turning the Arc

by Robert L. Bitzky

Tips on how to set the parameters for GMAW short arc welding

TRUMPF names Benz head of TruServices and Smart Services

Christine Benz has been named head of TruServices and Smart Services by TRUMPF Inc., effective October 1.

CN to buy 1,500 grain hopper cars

Rail carrier CN plans to acquire 1,500 new generation, high-capacity, grain hopper cars with delivery starting in January of 2021.

Reshaping the Future

by Noelle Stapinsky

Diversification and collaboration keep Canada’s tool, die and mould sector healthy and growing

$100 million for manufacturing: Harper election promise

Prime Minister Stephen Harper says if the Conservatives are re-elected, the government will create a $100 million Manufacturing Technology Demonstration Fund to support projects in advanced manufacturing. Harper's election promise is the latest in a slew of promises from federal party leaders about how they plan to support manufacturing in Canada if their respective governments are elected.

Choosing a welding helmet

by Jamy Bulan

Balancing safety, productivity and comfort

Stay In Touch

twitter facebook linkedIn