Double-sided square rough milling insertsClick image to enlarge

In the metalworking industry, ensuring a high-grade surface finish has always been one of the main directions in cutting tool development. This is also true for indexable face milling cutters.

Despite significant improvement in the high surface quality of milled surfaces, tool designers still believe that available resources have not yet been exhausted and that intelligent application of the last generations of advanced milling cutters can substantially improve surface texture.

When considering an indexable milling cutter, the key factors that determine the quality of a generated surface are the cutter’s geometry and accuracy.  Both characteristics are mainly related to inserts carried by the cutter.

Powder metallurgy processing has enabled the development of carbide inserts with complex shapes, ensuring optimal cutting geometry while maintaining substantially increased accuracy of inserts as sintered inserts. Not surprisingly, such advancements in technology have significantly improved the surface finish in face milling. However, when indexable milling cutters were successfully applied to machining high-strength materials, and manufacturers started to notice hard milling as an alternative to grinding, the metalworking industry started demanding the higher surface finish grades provided by milling.

An indexable face milling cutter is a multi-tooth tool. More teeth translates into more productivity. This is an undeniable advantage of the cutter. But in terms of surface texture, a large number of teeth may be a problem. A fine distinction in teeth protrusion leads to irregular feed for the teeth and contributes to chatter, which will ultimately affect the surface finish.

It is perfectly clear that insert accuracy can be considerably increased by grinding. Moreover, grinding provides a sharp cutting edge that is very important in maintaining cutting action and preventing plastic deformation of metal in fine milling, which features shallow depths of cut. Ensuring a highly accurate cutting edge requires grinding both the top and side surfaces of an insert. This may cancel the advantages of powder metallurgy in generating complicated surfaces to provide the required rake and clearance angles along a cutting edge. To avoid such an adverse impact, tool engineers should be very resourceful when designing the inserts intended for fine grinding.

An important factor regarding tooth accuracy loss is the fact that the insert pocket in a cutter has its own dimensional and form tolerances.  As a result, even for ideally precise inserts, teeth protrusion will vary—within acceptable limits (although this cannot ensure extra fine surface finish when compared to grinding). One way to overcome this problem is by using a fly cutter that carries only one insert. The fly cutter that is successfully used in various milling applications facilitates a smooth and clean cut, providing excellent surface texture parameters. But then again, productivity in this case is far below multi-tooth indexable face mills.

How to solve a difficult situation and find an acceptable balance between surface quality and productivity? The cutting tool manufacturer has developed different responses.

An integrated wiper flat with a specially shaped minor cutting edge is a classical element of various milling inserts. Its width should be greater than the feed per revolution. Despite being called flat, the minor edge sometimes has a complex geometry to compensate for the negative effect of wear development. When an insert is mounted on a cutter, the wiper flat sits parallel to the machined surface. Hence, the surface will be formed by the most protruding insert of the cutter. Introducing a wiper flat in an insert design is an effective way to improve surface finish.  And even today, rough milling inserts may have an integrated wiper (fig. 1).

Iscar's DoveIQMill family face mill carries double-sided inserts with a wide wiper flat and are intended for rough and semi-rough milling with surface roughness that usually features semi-finish to finish passes. The cutters delivered on the hopes of their designers—and the adoption of the cutters in various processes has resulted in the cancellation of finish milling operations. The cutters provide roughness Ra up to 0.4 µm (16 µin) when milling steel and cast iron.

Increasing the number of teeth in big-diameter face mills and fine pitch cutters determines the appropriate growth of the integrated wiper width, which has a natural bound due to design and dimensional limitations. In such cases, a high surface finish can be achieved with the use of a specially designed wiper insert (or two inserts for large-sized tools), where the wiper flat is significantly wider than the standard one. This insert is mounted in the same pocket but protrudes several tenths of a millimeter (or hundredths of an inch) axially relative to the standard insert (fig. 2).

Very good results can be reached by applying adjustable milling cutters that utilize different mechanisms to adjust the position of an insert cutting edge within very strict limits (only several microns). But the beneficial adjustability of cutting tools has a flip side as well; it is spider work, which takes time.

A desirable solution looks like a tool that after mounting an insert has no adjusting requirements needed to achieve high surface quality grade. That is why improving accuracy and advanced geometries remain the mainstream in updating indexable cutters for finish face milling.

At the same time, cutting tool manufacturers offer unique solutions that attract attention with their originality. An example is Iscar's TangFin family of milling cutters with tangentially clamped inserts with wide integrated wiper flats (fig. 3) are positioned in a cutter with a gradual displacement in both radial and axial directions, and therefore each insert cuts a small section of the machined material, providing an extra fine surface finish with roughness Ra up to 0.1 μm (4 μin).

For ensuring a high surface quality in milling relatively small faces, mainly bounded by shoulders, Iscar developed dedicated exchangeable solid carbide heads in a diameter range of 12–50 mm (0.472–2.000 in) for its Multi-Master and T-Face families (fig. 4). The heads are fully ground and provide high precision, facilitate a sharp cutting edge, and enable a greater number of teeth when compared to mills with indexable inserts of the same diameter. In combination, these features guarantee high-performance finish milling.

A tendency to decrease machining allowance due to the active introduction of technologies for precise workpiece production and 3D printing makes the issue of obtaining a high surface finish through face milling particularly relevant. Can toolmakers find a prompt, simple, and effective answer to the new needs of manufacturing? The near future will tell.

Andrei Petrilin is a Technical Manager with Iscar. For more information about this process go to www.iscar.ca

Schunk gripping system wins New Product of the Year

Schunk has announced that its new Adheso gripper system has won first place in the New Product of the Year Awards at the 2021 Assembly Show.

CWB Foundation collaborates to boost skilled trades

The CWB Welding Foundation, Bruce Power, Bluewater District School Board (BWDSB), Bruce-Grey Catholic District School Board (BGCDSB) and UA Canada are partnering to help local youth access apprenticeships and careers.

High feed milling tools

The new High Feed 2 line of small diameter high feed milling tools from Seco focus on bringing high levels of productivity and reliability to modern CNC machines.

FABTECH Canada 2014 Expands

The organizers of FABTECH Canada have announced they are expanding the 2014 event, slated for March 18 to 20 at the Toronto Congress Centre.

Mazak completes Kentucky spindle rebuild facility

Mazak Corp. has completed the expansion of its Spindle Rebuild Department as part of a $15 million investment in its Florence, Ken.-based manufacturing campus.

Irving Oil $200 M project a boon to Atlantic Canada

Irving Oil has announced plans to invest $200 million in a turnaround project at its Sain John, NB, facility that is expected to generate approximately 3,000 jobs for onsite workers.

BLM Group announces new Canada regional sales manager

BLM Group USA has announced the appointment of Danyel (Dan) Benoit as regional sales manager, Eastern Canada. 

Auto companies readying for new content requirements under USMCA

Canadian automakers are looking at their supply chains to make sure they’re prepared for the new regional content rules that are part of the new US Mexico Canada Agreement (USMCA), which replaces NAFTA.

Yaskawa, ESAB building robotic welding cells

The ESAB Group Inc. and robot systems manufacturer Yaskawa have partnered to jointly develop and market a line of pre-engineered robotic welding systems.

Mazak hosts Discover Education Automation event

November 8-9, 2018, Mazak Canada will host a two-day Discover Automation Education Event, focusing on how to automate low to medium-volume/high-mix machining production.

Fanuc partners with Montreal's Vention

Fanuc has partnered with Vention, a Montreal-based cloud manufacturing automation platform (MAP) company, to sell collaborative robotics. Centered around the FANUC CRX cobot, this alliance will allow users to design and order complete, end-to-end robot cells directly from the Vention cloud platform.

GF Machining Solutions breaks ground on new Canadian facility

GF Machining Solutions has held a groundbreaking ceremony to celebrate the announcement of an expansion in Canada.

SPI Lasers rebrands under TRUMPF name

TRUMPF Group has announced that its TRUMPF Laser- und Systemtechnik GmbH division will combine the business operations of SPI Lasers UK Ltd. to bring advantages in industrial applications via both disk and fiber technology and enhance customer service offerings.

Canadian auto industry posts big gains

Canada's automotive industry continues to post solid gains, with several major automotive companies posting sales gains and one automotive parts manufacturer posting a 6.6 per cent sales increase in its second quarter over the 2016 quarter.

Westway Machinery to sell Mazak lasers

Westway Machinery, Mississauga, ON, has formed a partnership with Mazak Optonics, Elgin, IL, to sell Mazak's laser cutting systems in Eastern Canada.

Stay In Touch

twitter facebook linkedIn