courtesy DMG Mori Click image to enlarge

Three-axis machining centres have long dominated the job shop world. But given that high-mix, low-volume work is the new normal for most machine shops, are they still the best choice?

By Kip Hanson

Walk into a typical machine shop and you’re likely to see a row of three-axis machining centres, each sporting a pair of six-inch Machinist’s vises and carousels filled with steep taper tooling. These popular machine tools are less expensive than their horizontal counterparts, simpler to set up, and it’s fairly easy to find people familiar with their programming and operations. Why change?

If your shop is machining large plates one day and small widgets the next, there's no need, as vertical machining centers provide the much-needed flexibility required to tackle such work. Also, if the majority of your jobs are simple parts requiring but one or two operations, the three-axis status quo is probably just fine, especially where higher production volumes are the norm and the shop can fill the entire machining center table with parts.   

Beyond medical

Many shops, however, face ever-dwindling order quantities and increased part complexity. Here, multiple fixtures, setups, and programs are required, driving up costs. And a large percentage of these parts are often smaller than a toaster—sometimes much smaller—leaving the traditional 20 x 40 machining centre table a mostly barren landscape. Still think three-axis verticals are the way to go?

Dave Lucius doesn’t, at least not in this scenario. The vice president of sales at Kitamura Machinery of USA Inc., Wheeling, Ill., points to the company’s MedCenter5AX five-axis vertical machining centre as an excellent solution for this last group of shops (as explained in the November 2020 issue of Shop Metalworking Technology). Since then, Kitamura has made it possible to add 12 or 24 pallets and up to 120 tools to the platform (even on existing machines), greatly increasing its ability to run unattended.

“We have a shop in New Jersey making bone plates for a large medical company and they’re seeing 90 per cent spindle utilization, seven days a week,” Lucius says. “We have a number of dental implant manufacturers who machine a tremendous amount of unique part numbers every day with practically no setup. And we have several government laboratories using our single pallet MedCenters for prototyping work. With or without automation, the machine offers a lot of capability in a very small footprint."

You might be thinking, ‘So what? We don’t make medical or dental parts, we do most of our prototyping on manual machines, and we certainly don’t have any five-axis work. I’ll stick with what’s kept the lights on and doors open for the past two decades.’

Meet the new paradigm

Maybe so, but consider this: when properly tooled, a compact, automation-ready machining centre like this makes it possible to produce the toaster-size and smaller parts mentioned earlier—whatever the industry—in a single operation, in very small quantities, and do so after everyone has gone home for the night. Better yet, you can fit two or more of them in the same space as most three-axis verticals.

“Three-axis verticals typically achieve 30 per cent utilization,” says Lucius. “We’re seeing 80 per cent or better with this approach, and ROI in as little as a year.”

Jeff Wallace, general manager for national engineering at DMG MORI USA Inc. in Hoffman Estates, Ill., agrees. "As everyone knows, it's hard to find workers at all these days, let alone ones who are talented, so the drumbeat we've been hearing is automate, automate, automate. Yes, medical and dental parts are candidates, but so are all manner of smallish components for the aerospace, automotive, and general industries. When equipped with a robot or pallet changing system, you can load up tens or hundreds of parts into one of our DMP 35 verticals, turn out the lights, and run it all night or even through the weekend.”

Introduced last June, the DMP 35 is a smaller version of DMG MORI's DMP 70. It's offered as a three-axis machine as standard, but has an optional five-axis configuration. And as Wallace indicates, the company also offers numerous automation solutions, the smallest of which—the tightly integrated WH 3 Cell—adds only 1.15 sq m (12.38 sq. ft.) of floor space to the DMP 35's already svelte 3.15 sq m (32.29 sq. ft.) footprint.

Gathering the puzzle pieces

Like Lucius, Wallace notes that there’s more to this equation than the machine and a robot. Because workholding plays such a large part in any automated machining scenario, the DMP series’ five-axis table is equipped with integral air activation, making it easy to load and unload pallets or individual parts. "In addition to the WH 3, we have customers using standalone drawer systems and robots, or a two-axis gantry that serves an entire row of machines stacked next to one another," he says.

One such workholding provider is EROWA Technology Inc. of Arlington Heights, Ill., where regional manager Fred Holzmacher notes that he’s equipping these and other CNC machine tools with the workholding just described as well as standalone pallet changing systems. “Our MTS zero-point workholding system is quite popular for production machining where positional tolerances are in the two to three tenths range (0.0051 to 0.0076 mm),” he says. “For anything closer than that, we have another system that gets you down to 80 millionths (0.002 mm) repeatability.”

Adoption of the digital twin is another crucial step in solving the automation puzzle. Wallace and Lucius each stressed the importance of toolpath simulation, especially in five-axis and 3+2 machining applications where quarters are typically tight. Not only does this eliminate crashes, but it significantly shortens setup times, often to zero.

Someone who knows all about it is Ivan Mikesic, product support manager for CAMplete at San Rafael, Calif.-based Autodesk Inc. He notes that the company has partnerships with many machine tool builders, Kitamura included, and works directly with their partners to develop accurate posting and simulation for their machines. Like the others, he emphasizes the need to simulate the machine environment.

“That’s true for any machining operation, but five-axis and 3+2 can require longer tool lengths so as to reach all of the workpiece as it swivels around the machine's rotary axes," he says. "Because of this, interference is a real possibility, as is an overtravel condition. This is even more likely on the compact machining centers we've been discussing. Not only that, but they're moving quite fast, so simulation is a must if you're going to avoid an expensive crash. By checking everything ahead of time, you also achieve a much higher level of confidence that when you send the program down to the machine, you know it's going to work correctly.”

www.autodesk.com

www.dmgmori.com

www.erowa.com

www.kitamura-machinery.com

Mazak smart factory concept exceeds ISO standards

The recent ISO recertification of Mazak Corp.'s Florence, KY, manufacturing operations, comes on the heels of the company's adoption of a new manufacturing concept it calls "iSMART Factory."

Advantages of a through-coolant spindle

Scott and Matt of Haas demonstrate some of the advantages of the Haas TSC system by comparing traditional flood coolant and through-spindle coolant on the same drilling application.

MC Machinery showcases manufacturing technology

MC Machinery opened its doors to customers on June 4 to showcase its wide range of machining and fabricating technologies, including a metal laser sintering hybrid milling machine and fiber laser cutting technology.

Peter Turton retires from CMTDA

Peter Turton has officially retired as executive director of the Canadian Machine Tool Distributors’ Association (CMTDA) after more than a decade leading the organization.

CWB Association introduces Training Supplement and Upskill Program

The CWB Association has introduced a new program that it says will offer various skills that help promote continued learning and upskilling within the steel industries.

Zeiss sets sights on car body metrology, automation

Zeiss Industrial Metrology has opened a new facility in Wixom, MI, dedicated to the latest developments for the process chain in car body metrology and automated inspection.

The equipment: DSA Precision

by Mary Scianna

DSA Precision Machining’s workholding investments include the Lang Makro-Grip vises and Quick-Point zero clamping system, and SPD electro-permanent magnetic chucks. The products were all purchased from workholding product distributor, Machine Tool Solutions Ltd., Brampton, ON.

New record reached for North American robot sales

The number of robots sold in North America set a new record in 2021, with 39,708 units sold at a value of $2 billion, a 14 per cent increase over the previous high in 2017, according to data released by the Association for Advancing Automation(A3).

SigmaNEST kicks off 2014 outdoor adventure contest

SigmaTEK Systems LLC has kicked-off its 2014 Outdoor Adventure give-away for North American manufacturers and fabricators.

Autonomous movers set for launch in 2024

BENTELER EV Systems, Beep Inc., and Mobileye have formed a strategic collaboration to develop and deploy automotive-grade, fully electric, autonomous movers in public and private communities across North America.

Racer Machinery picked for Siemens' control roll-out

Cambridge, Ont.-based Racer Machinery has been chosen to be part of Siemens’ “field experience” phase of its global rollout of Sinumerik One CNC control.

Canada investing in domestic semiconductor, photonics industries

The federal government is looking to invest in the domestic development and supply of semiconductors and photonics, key components for industries served by job shops.

Coming together in crisis

Manufacturers are a focused bunch, with their attention firmly placed on producing high quality products at the best possible margins.

MAG Group gets new owner, Fair Friend Group

MAG Group is now part of the Fair Friend Group. While the purchase price was not disclosed FFG's machine tool division is expected to generate annual sales of more than US $2.3 billion, including MAG Group figures.

Stay In Touch

twitter facebook linkedIn