OSG is one of the growing number of cutting tool manufacturers to jump on the barrel milling bandwagon. Shown here is its indexable PFB-BR style insert.   image: OSG USAClick image to enlarge

Circle segment cutters are reshaping how shops attack complex surfacing operations

 by Staff Writter

Watching a ball nose end mill trace a mould cavity is the very definition of tedium. Back and forth, back and forth, for hour after hour of minimal metal removal and slow but steady tool wear. It’s like watching paint dry. The same is true for turbine and propeller blades, orthopedic implants, forming dies, and similarly challenging, three-dimensional machined surfaces. 

Granted, this has been the standard approach for decades, so what’s the use of complaining? For that matter, why change it? Darryl Latoski has answers to both questions. The milling product manager for Iscar Tools Inc., Oakville, Ont., represents one of a growing number of cutting tool manufacturers who have seen the light on circle segment cutters, a.k.a. barrel mills, and will tell you these unique end mills can easily offer a four-fold increase in productivity. 


Off to the races
One example of this comes from a well-known Canadian aerospace manufacturer. The company was recently machining a series of engine doors—a part that can best be described as a large aluminum potato chip—on one of its Mazak Variaxis 730-5X five-axis, 50-taper machining centres. Using a 3/8 in. diameter (9.5 mm) two-flute ball nose end mill at a 0.014 in. (.35 mm) stepover, its convex side took 55 minutes to complete. Its opposite side contains a series of milled pockets for weight reduction and was much faster, requiring just 17 minutes using a 3/16 in. (4.75 mm) ball end mill and 0.04 in. (1.02 mm) stepover. 

With 146 engine doors on the order, the company was faced with 175 hours of machining time on those two operations alone. They called Latoski. “We have a very good relationship with them, so they were willing to work with us to dial everything in,” he says. “We ended up replacing their ball nose cutters with our Multi-Master lens-style indexable barrel mills and were able to increase the stepover amounts up to three times, saving them 134 hours on that job alone. The results were like night and day.”

None of this is unusual. As its name implies, the flutes on a circle segment cutter contain just that—segments of large radii, some measuring a metre or more across—that make these large stepovers possible. So-called lens, taper, oval, and barrel forms are available, each with distinct uses and each requiring the correct toolpaths together with the right CNC machine tool. 

Says Latoski, “there’s no doubt that the programming is a bit more complicated due to the size of the cutter segment relative to the workpiece. Fortunately, Mastercam and Open Mind Technologies and a few other CAM providers now offer this capability. But the machine tool is equally important—you need very accurate motion control in all five axes, along with a decent buffer size and strong lookahead capabilities. Put it all together, though, and you’re off to the races.”

Eye openers

Steve McBride is a senior high speed machining specialist at OSG USA Inc., St. Charles, Ill. Although new to circle segment milling, his machining experience dates back to the late 60s as he watched five-axis milling and CAM systems profoundly change the die-mold and aerospace industries. McBride is curious to see if barrel milling will have a similar effect. 

“When we got word on our new barrel and lens product line, I ordered a handful of tools and teamed up with a friend of mine from Gosiger, a machine tool distributor here in Dayton, Ohio,” McBride says. “We sat down, looked at the different cutters, and designed a fairly basic three-axis part that we could use to evaluate the process. The first thing I noticed was how well they cut 50 Rockwell tool steel. The second eye-opener was how large of a stepover you can take without changing the part surface finish.”

In one recent application, a Multi-Master lens-style indexable barrel mill from Iscar Tool increased stepover amounts by three-fold, saving the customer more than 100 hours on a single job.  image: Iscar ToolsClick image to enlargeAs with Iscar’s Latoski, McBride notes that programming a barrel tool requires a different approach. For help, he reached out to Canadian software developer Cam-Tool of Oldcastle, Ont., which specializes in five-axis mold and die work. They supported McBride throughout the testing process, which in this admittedly simple test case, was largely a matter of increasing the stepover amounts. “We went from 0.2 mm (0.008 in.) up to ten times that amount with very little change in surface finish,” he says. “That’s a ten-fold increase. What’s most amazing to me is that it’s taken so long for the industry to develop this technology. It’s a game-changer.”


Old friends
Dan Doiron is no stranger to circle segment cutters. The product manager for milling at Emuge-Franken USA, West Boylston, Mass., Doiron has been helping customers with tool selection and programming questions since 2016. He says the company has the largest selection of solid carbide barrel cutters in the industry and pioneered the technology in close collaboration with CAD/CAM developer Open Mind Technologies, making Emuge-Franken the first to introduce them to the North American market. The company also works closely with Mastercam, whose software supports barrel cutter milling.

Although circle segment milling can be performed on practically any CNC machining centre, a high performance five axis machine will generally produce the best results.  image: Emuge-Franken USAClick image to enlargeFirst to the finish line kudos aside, Doiron points out that many shops remain leery of barrel milling, much of which comes down to programming. “It can be both scary and time-consuming to develop new processes, especially if the job quantities don’t justify the effort,” he says. “However, the potential for greater productivity here is so significant, I highly encourage shops to evaluate it for themselves.”

Evan Duncanson, milling application specialist at Emuge-Franken, offers another potato chip analogy. “The parts that work best with circle segment machining are those with large flowing surfaces, kind of like a full potato chip bag,” he said. “Now, crumple that bag up and you’re left with all these creases and tight corners that a barrel mill with its large radius segments might not be able to reach. These complex geometries also make programming more difficult, never mind the fact that you’ll need a machine tool able to drive the cutter through all these dancing movements without hesitating or slowing down too much, which tends to mess up the beautiful surfaces you’re trying to create.”

Despite these challenges, Duncanson notes that the lion’s share of mould cavities, blades and blisks, and many medical components are quite workable. “Send us the CAD model,” he said. “We’ll let you know whether the part is a good candidate, and if so, will tell you what tool we recommend, what cycle time reduction you can expect, and help with the programming if needed. There are hurdles with any new technology, but for the right application, this is one you definitely want to jump.” SMT

Sharpest rise in manufacturing production since February: IHS Markit PMI

A sustained rebound in output and new business levels continued in October, with a modest improvement in business conditions in Canadian manufacturing, according to the IHS Markit Purchasing Managers’ Index (PMI), released November 1.

Halifax hosts 25th Skills Canada National Competition

On Tuesday May 28, Skills/Compétences Canada will host the 25th Skills Canada National Competition (SCNC) in Halifax.

US Cutting Tool Orders hit $175.5 million in April

Cutting tool orders in the U.S. totaled $175.5 million in April, a 3.8 per cent year-over-year increase, according to the U.S. Cutting Tool Institute (USCTI) and AMT – The Association For Manufacturing Technology.

Doosan North America names new CEO

Doosan Machine Tools has named James Kim the new CEO of its North American operations. Mr. Kim has spent the past 37 years working at Doosan in a variety of roles.

CTMA launches new trades mentoring award

Igor Babamov of Advanced Machining Services Inc., Windsor, ON, is the first recipient of a new award that recognizes mentors of skilled trades people.

Fanuc reaches major robot milestone

Fanuc has produced its 750,000th industrial robot, representing a record high point in the robotics industry.

A stark reality: the case for automation in welding

Pipe welding operations are being squeezed on both ends of the talent spectrum and it’s only going to get worse.

Lion Electric and Transit Truck Bodies launch electric truck

Montreal-based Lion Electric Company, a manufacturer of all-electric medium and heavy-duty vehicles, and Transit Truck Bodies, are launching an electric heavy-duty truck for last-mile delivery.

Hurco acquires Milltronics and Takumi

Hurco Companies Inc. has acquired two machine tool builders, Milltronics Manufacturing Co. and Takumi Machinery Co. Ltd.

Go Big, or Go Home

by Kip Hanson

Turning gargantuan parts? Four cutting tool manufacturers weigh in with recommendations

Global mobile robot shipments reach milestone

There were just over 100,000 mobile robots shipped globally in 2021, the first time this milestone has been reached, according to an Online Robotics magazine report.

$18.2 M in fed funding for automotive innovation


Two Canadian companies will receive funding totalling $18.2 million to develop innovations that have the potential to make cars lighter, more fuel efficient and better performing.

Magna International supports skilled trades

Skills Ontario will receive a $100,000 investment from Magna International in support of the 2017 Skills Ontario Competition, Skills Ontario Young Women’s Initiatives, and Skills Ontario Summer Camps.

GM to build EV battery material in Quebec

General Motors and POSCO Chemical will build a $500 million facility in Becancour, Que., to produce cathode active material (CAM), an integral component of electric-car batteries.

$54.4 B record high for April 2017 manufacturing stats

Manufacturing sales rolse 1.1 per cent to a record high of $54.4 billion in April. The icrease was due mainly to higher sales in the petroleum and coal product, and primary metal industries, according to the latest figures from Statistics Canada.

Stay In Touch

twitter facebook linkedIn